I had no interest in The Epic Tales of Captain Underpants, with an icon of an oval-shaped being in his underwear, until I discovered that one of the main characters is gay.
The tv series is based on a series of illustrated children's books (1997-2015) staring two fourth grade best friends, Harold Hutchins (blond) and George Beard (black), who can make their sadistic, fun-hating principal transform into the titular superhero to fight grade-school supervillains. Most of the villains have some connection to farting, belching, or pooping: Professor Poopypants, the Wedgie Woman, the Bionic Booger Boy, Tippy Tinkletrousers, Sir Stinks-a-Lot.
In the last book in the series, the boys travel forward in time to meet their future selves and their families: George has a wife, and Harold has a husband. They both have kids. This is no big reveal -- "Wow, you mean Harold was gay all along?" The partners are presented matter-of-factly, without surprise or commentary.
I suspect that author Dav Pilkey didn't plan on Harold being gay from the start;it was just what made sense as he was bringing the series to a close. But to see if there are glimpses into Harold's sexual identity early on, I checked out Season 2, Episode 8 of the tv series (the only episode that mentions a girl).
Scene 1: The narrator (Sean Astin) identifies the two boys: George (Ramone Hamilton, below) with a flat top, and Harold (Jay Gragnani) with wavy blond hair. They're showing Erica their ideas for a new comic book character, Plungerina. She disapproves, which makes them recoil in self-doubt: "I'm a hack! I'm no good! I should give up comics!" Finally she likes one of the ideas.
Scene 2: We see the comic book. At a sports stadium, the toilets are all clogged. A clog-monster climbs out of a toilet and attacks. Captain Underpants (Nat Faxon, top photo) fights him, and is defeated. Superhero Plungerina saves the day.
Scene 3: At school, everyone is reading the new comic book. Erica claims that Plungerina is even better than Captain Underpants, which causes the boys to screech to a halt. "How can you say that?" To prove that Captain Underpants is superior, they clog all the toilets at school (thankfully not with poop) so a real-life clog monster will emerge and Principal Krupp will morph into Captain Underpants and save them.
But Principal Krupp and Melvinborg (a future cyborg version of their enemy Melvin) are attending a principal's convention far away. The school is helpless!
Scene 4: Teacher Mr. Rected (all teacher names are puns) uses the bathroom, flushes the toilet, and is inundated by water, transforming into Cloggernaut. And Captain Underpants isn't around to save them. Fortunately, a real-life Plungerina arrives to clobber Cloggernaut. Erica was right -- Plungerina is superior! If their comic book stories always come to life, could they conjure up some high grades, or pizzas, or cute boys/girls?
Scene 5: Who is Plungerina? An adult, so not Erica. The boys interrogate their teachers: Miss Anthrope, Miss Heard, the Lunch Lady -- but find no suspects.
Mr. Rected returns to the bathroom. The toilet is still clogged, so he morphs into Cloggernaut again!
I'll stop the scene-by-scene there.
Beefcake: No. The characters are all stylized.
Heterosexism: None. No one expresses any romantic or erotic interest of any sort. Erica is a big sister/antagonist, not an object of desire.
Gay Characters: No one expresses any same sex interest. The only boys shown are antagonists as well.
What about Harold and George? Usually inseparable best friends have a strong gay subtext, but here I didn't notice anything. The boys are not differentiated in any way; they have no distinctive personality traits, no disagreements about strategy, nothing that would provide conflict. Maybe a gay subtext requires conflict?
Gay Actors: No information on Nat Flaxon or Jay Gragnani. Ramone Hamilton lives in West Hollywood, but since he's only 15 years old, it probably wasn't his idea.
Toilet Humor: Incessant.
My Suggestion: Wait for the boys to grow up.
There's a feature film that's heavy on the buddy bonding.
ReplyDelete