By the late 1990s, he was starting to bulk up, and the teen magazines started going wild. They specialized in shots of his bare chest peeking out from his shirt, as if he had been caught in the midst of getting dressed (or undressed).
Lots of gay content:
1. Gay-vague "not into girls" roles on Party of Five (1997-98) and Seventh Heaven (1997-2004)/
2. Broken Hearts Club (2000): Andrew played Kevin, one of a group of gay friends who hang out in West Hollywood (others include Timothy Olyphant, Dean Cain, and Zach Branff).
3. O (2001), an updating of Othello. His Michael Cassio, a high school basketball player, buddy-bonds with Odin (Mekhi James).
Andrew is rumored to be bisexual in real life, but he hasn't made any public statements.