I find it derivative of 1980s high school nerd movies, complete with sneering bullies, sadistic teachers, and The Girl walking across the room in slow motion while every guy in the class stares at her in rapture. Hetero-horniness is endemic; gay people do not exist.
And I have a lot of nit-picks:
1. It's Michigan, but always warm and sunny, even in winter.
2. Characters are introduced, then vanish, never to be seen or mentioned again.
3. The fundamentalist Christian girl crosses herself -- only Catholics do that.
4. And her church holds a dance -- fundamentalist Christians do not dance.
5. The time frames make no sense. They go trick-or-treating for hours in broad daylight. Lindsay goes to dinner at the Mean Girl's house, hours of plot time pass, and she goes home -- where her family is just sitting down to dinner. Do they eat at 9:00 pm?
Still, the characters have an endearing quality, the 1980s references give me a nostalgic glow, and there is ample beefcake.
Here are the top 12 beefcake highlights:
The Freaks: a group of slackers and stoners (although they never mention pot).
1. Teddy bear Ken (Seth Rogen)
2. James Dean wannabe Danny (James Franco)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5a0f8/5a0f82ca79980ef2830f08d014733b136feae4ac" alt=""
If these three sound familiar, it's because they've been starring in each others' movies for 17 years.
Plus Mean Girl Kim (Busy Phillips) and focus character Lindsay Weir (Linda Cardellini)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/708b2/708b293791e16283a47d48d0b9b02693d16dfdfb" alt=""
The Geeks: a group of underdeveloped, non-athletic Star Wars fans:
4. Tall, thin, laconic Bill (Martin Starr). He's still tall, thin, and laconic.
5. Jewish stereotype Neal (Samm Levine). The hottest of the cast, then and now.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e9105/e9105066cf4de6b98eb7d4dcc1721684fd0ad5db" alt=""
More after the break.