Since Baby Reindeer features a Scotch comedian trapped in London, and one of Robert Oberst's strong men was Scottish, I figured it was time for some Scots studs.
Beefcake, gay subtexts, and queer representation in mass media from the 1950s to the present
Scene 1: Mike (Adam) is trying to sell his brand of tequila to a bar owner, using Dave (Zac) as a plant. Except the bartender knows him -- they hang out! And the guys try this every couple of weeks. He buys the tequila anyway. The guys hug. Zac is established as heterosexual in Minute 1.
Uh-oh, the montage was an unreliable narrator. A lot of those parties turned into disasters. So Mom and Dad lay down the law: at the upcoming wedding, they must each bring a date (they specify a girl). How will that keep the fireworks from destroying a camper, or grandpa from being pushed into his birthday cake?
Oh, and it turns out that the second couple is their sister Jeannie and her fiance Erik (Sam Richardson)
Character development: Mike is aggressive, easily-angered, and a schemer, while Dave is quiet, stable, and has to be talked into the craziness. Mike saved Dave from bullies when they were in school. Shouldn't Dave be saving Mike? Zac Efron is about twice as muscular as Adam Devine, and has a bigger dick, and everybody knows that you need a big dick to fight bullies.
Meanwhile, the guys wonder where they can find nice, respectable girls to take to the wedding: Match.com, Tinder, Grindr (really?), Craigslist?
They post their ad - two incredibly gorgeous guys offer a free weekend in Hawaii -- and the number of responses breaks the internet.
Bob (Bob Turton) sees the ad. His friends tell him it's just for girls; he replies "that's not a dealbreaker," and goes to the interview in drag. He explains that he's new to drag, but he just got out of a divorce, and wants to fuck. They refuse graciously.
Two lesbians respond: "I'm not really looking for a heteronormative relationship." That's not what heteronormative means, ladies.
The full review, with three nude photos (one of Zac's butt), is on RG Beefcake and Boyfriends.
Scene 1: Rome, 1961, atmospheric black and white. Having just killed someone, a man with his face obscured puts on his shoes and hat and starts dragging the body down a palatial staircase.
Scene 2: Six months earlier, New York. Tom (Andrew Scott) gets up in his run-down room in a residential hotel, walks the mean streets, steals someone's mail, and writes out a fake "payment overdue" notice
Then he goes to a bar and starts one of those highly-closeted 1960s hookups with a guy named Al (Bokeem Woodbine) Whoops, no, Al is a private detective, hired to find him and hook him up with the wealthy Mr. Herbert Greenleaf. Tom refuses, then leaves to ride the subway and walk the mean streets some more.Back home, someone left his business card: From the IRS!
Scene 3: Tom continues his scam: he steals payment checks, then calls or writes the sender, claims that it was lost in the mail, and has them send a new check to his own post office box. Nice establishing shots of the art deco post office and bank.
Uh-oh, the clerk thinks something is wrong, and goes to consult the manager. Tom has to run away, and close down the whole collection agency scam! What to do next? Maybe Herbert Greenleaf's job won't be so bad...
Scene 4: Greenleaf Shipbuilders. Tom is escorted past the big ships to the office, where Herbert Greenleaf tells him about the job: his son Dickie, Tom's old acquaintance, has been living in Italy for years, pretending to be a writer or a painter, but really just goofing off. Greenleaf wants Tom to convince Dickie to come home.
Why Tom? They didn't know each other well. Because none of Dickie's other friends wanted the job. Why would someone on the bottom of Dickie's friends list, who he doesn't know well and doesn't care about, be able to talk him into leaving Italy? Tom must have a really big dick.
Scene 5: While he's considering the job, Tom has dinner with the Greenleafs. Back story dump: He went to Princeton. When he was young, his parents drowned. Uh-oh, maybe he killed them. Then they look at some photos of Dickie when he was young, in college, and now, in Atrapi, with Marge -- "girlfriend, friend, who knows?" So Dickie is gay.
Scene 6: Tom at the tailor's, inspecting the clothes the Greenleafs bought for him. He gets his passport, signs travelers' checks, throws out his scam checks, and we're on the Orient Express! In the Swiss alps; I guess in those days you flew in through Paris?
He writes to his Aunt Dottie, who is getting a dental procedure -- which we see, for some reason: "You're free of me now, and I of you." I like the slow, moody structure, with the beautiful, weird shots of fire escapes, catwalks, and sculptures, but it's a little too slow. How much time do we need to devote to Tom brooding?.
Atrapi, finally! He asks someone, in bad Italian, for Richard Greenleaf, and is directed up endless stairs, through arches and corridors, up more stairs. to a villa. Where he is told that Richard is down on the beach! Is this supposed to be a comedy?
The beach is deserted -- oh, there in the distance is Dickie, lying down, fully clothed, with Marge's head on his thigh. Tom wakes them and introduces himself, pretending that this is a chance meeting. Dickie doesn't remember him, but invites him to go for a swim. Uh-oh, Tom is afraid of the water, since his parents drowned. He won't set foot into the water.
More Dickie after the break
Ulp, surely we're not going to learn that all gay men are sexual predators out to seduce or assault hapless straight guys. I thought that myth faded into oblivion back in the 1970s. I'd better review the episode.
Scene 1: Looking very haggard, wild-eyed, sleazy, like a drug addict in search of a fix, Donny (Richard Gad) bursts into the police station to report his stalker. He wonders why he can't tell the cop about Martha groping him and attacking his girlfriend, or about her history of arrests? He's suddenly reliving a traumatic event that happened at the Edinburgh Fringe Festival in 2011.
Ok, so "I got circumcized today" -- pulling out gigantic scissors. "See, I'm saying I have a big penis. It's funny." Did this guy even workshop his material?
Scene 3: The pubkeeper gives him an admission card to the Luna Bar -- fell out of someone's wallet. He goes, hoping to schmooze with the Fringe Festival elites. Still looking haggard, wild-eyed, and sleazy. Maybe he could, like, wear a nice shirt? He latches onto a guy who was on the writing staff of the fringe movie Cottonmouth, and invites him to his show, "LOL on Cancer". Nope, not interested.
Scene 4: Darrien comes to his show, listens to his ridiculous jokes and performance bits, and offers to give him some pointers.
Montage of Darrien's tips, like "Make eye contact," and the pub gradually fills up as people like the performance. Donny tells us that he went out with Darrien every night to a private club (not gay). So, are we supposed to conclude that they're dating? Why not just say so, or have them kiss?
We do learn that Darrien is a "polyamorous pansexual." Um...polyamorous means that you have more than one permanent romantic partner.
Scene 5: Darrien pushes Donny into the pub bathroom, stands kissing-close, and asks "Are you ready?" Donny: "Ready for anything." Sounds like he's up for some snogging. But it's not sex, it's cocaine.
Then Darrien returns to London, and stops contacting Donny. "It felt strange."
Scene 6: When the festival ends, Donny goes to acting class at Oxford. We see some of their ridiculous exercises: be a flame; mimic an ape. He gets a girlfriend, but he misses Darrien. So are you interested in him, or not? Then out of nowhere Darrien calls and asks him to collaborate on a project.
Scene 7: Donny arrives at Darrien's elite flat, gets a tour, and shows his script: about a lawyer who decides to become a pro wrestler at age 50, and is torn between two worlds. Darrien is not impressed, but humors him. I'm guessing we're supposed to be reading them as straight buddies.
Darrien asks if he wants to get really high, and gives him MDMA and GHB. Hey GHB is a date rape drug! But if you want to have sex with him, why not just ask?
More homophobia after the break
In the second scene, Josh is telling a grade school class that his friend got a hamster shoved all the way up his butt. This is based on the homophobic urban legend that gay men like shoving rodents up there.
I can't really tell if the pilot is homophobic or transphobic based on two brief scenes, but since these were the scenes that Dominic Russo used to draw viewer interest, it seems likely that gay/trans identity was going to be a major focus.